Quote of the week

Regard must be had to the higher standard of conduct expected from public officials, and the number of falsehoods that have been put forward by the Public Protector in the course of the litigation.  This conduct included the numerous “misstatements”, like misrepresenting, under oath, her reliance on evidence of economic experts in drawing up the report, failing to provide a complete record, ordered and indexed, so that the contents thereof could be determined, failing to disclose material meetings and then obfuscating the reasons for them and the reasons why they had not been previously disclosed, and generally failing to provide the court with a frank and candid account of her conduct in preparing the report. The punitive aspect of the costs order therefore stands.

Public Protector v South African Reserve Bank (CCT107/18) [2019] ZACC 29 (22 July 2019)
8 December 2006

Does Mbeki think corruption is a problem or not?

In his letter from the President, Thabo Mbeki today blasts the newspapers who publish stories of corruption about ANC leaders. President Mbeki refers specifically to the story published last week in the Sunday Times that hinted that cabinet ministers such as Naledi Pandor was involved in corrupt dealings involving Gautrain.

He points out that this story is sensationalistic and, let’s admit it, wrong. He then concludes that “the most outrageous untruths” about the ANC and its members’ involvement in corruption is published because of a racist mindset prevalent among many in South Africa.

I have in the past made the point that a central and permanent feature of the racism experienced by black people over many centuries has been the stereotype that as black people we are inherently amoral and corrupt. Thus some in our country and elsewhere in the world know it as a matter of fact that our government is bound to be amoral and corrupt.

Because of this, it is very easy successfully to market all manner of deliberate falsehoods about the ANC and our government, counting on the stubborn persistence of an insulting stereotype to give credibility to the most outrageous untruths.

President Mbeki does, of course, have a point. One only has to listen to phone-in programmes on the radio to know that for some among us (as the President would say) the ANC or by extension black people are terminally corrupt because of the colour of their skin.

This is a master narrative that seems to be deeply embedded in the DNA of some South Africans and I think newspapers often, without even knowing it, pick up on this and make scandals where none exist. The Mail & Guardian has in the past published “scandal-type” stories that did not seem to contain any scandal at all.

The problem is, however, that corruption in government (but also in private business – think about Bret Kebble) does occur and is often exposed by the newspapers. In fact, almost every week there are new stories in the papers about councellors stealing money or giving contracts to friends and family and those implicated hardly ever bother to deny the specifics of a story.

Instead they often vilify those who expose the corruption, calling them racists or alleging some dark conspiracy, only to be proven wrong later. Recal Tony Yengeni who took out a full page add in the Sunday Times claiming that the allegations against him was a racist plot only to find himself behind bars.

I always check on the response: did the ANC leader or official deny the specifics of a charge or did he or she merely heap abuse on those making the allegations? Jacob Zuma, for example, has NEVER denied the specific allegations against him. He only proclaims his innocence and blames the media and dark forces.

It is far too easy for President Mbeki to point to one mistake by a newspaper and then to imply that all allegations of corruption against the ANC and its leaders are based on racism. It’s a good high school debating strategy but surely the President of a country should do better.

What about Oilgate? What about the recent funding scandal about the ANC’s investment company who was awarded several government tenders. Not a peep from the President about these issues, perhaps because these are not as easily dismissed as the stupid Sunday Times story.

President Mbeki’s position is also inconsistent because only last week he railed against people joining the ANC to get positions and contracts – the worst kind of corruption which is often exposed by the media.

It seems to suggest the most troubling mindset: if one is the leader of the ANC one can berate those in one’s party for being corrupt, but if a newspaper exposes corruption it is inevitably because of a racist agenda. Once again, it sends a signal that the party is more important than the people.

2015 Constitutionally Speaking | website created by Idea in a Forest