An ‘important purpose of section 34 [of the Constitution] is to guarantee the protection of the judicial process to persons who have disputes that can be resolved by law’ and that the right of access to court is ‘foundational to the stability of an orderly society. It ensures the peaceful, regulated and institutionalised mechanisms to resolve disputes, without resorting to self-help. The right of access to court is a bulwark against vigilantism, and the chaos and anarchy which it causes. Construed in this context of the rule of law and the principle against self-help in particular, access to court is indeed of cardinal importance’.The right guaranteed s34 would be rendered meaningless if court orders could be ignored with impunity:the underlying purposes of the right — and particularly that of avoidance of self-help — would be undermined if litigants could decide which orders they wished to obey and which they wished to ignore.
Journalists seem hardwired to exaggerate threats to press freedom and they are not averse to making themselves the hero of their own stories either. I was therefore rather sceptical when I first read the lead story in the Sunday Times this morning.
The story claims that its editor, Mondli Makanya, and its deputy managing editor, Jocelyn Maker, are going to be arrested because of the possession of the health records of Dr Beetroot, Manto Tshabalala-Msimang. Inside the paper Justice Malala turns up the heat even further, arguing that President Mbeki is a liar and that he and his acolytes are raping
Aren’t they being a bit hysterical just because one two of their own are going to be arrested for breaking the law? Surely they do not think they are above the law like Jackie Selebi? And surely the clause in the National Health Act that prohibits the possession of a person’s health records is so overbroad and so vague that it will most probably be found to be unconstitutional if challenged.?
And yet in the present climate – what with Vusi Pikoli and Nozizwe Madladla-Routledge fired and Jackie Selebi sitting pretty – it is not so easy to dismiss the people at the Sunday Times as hysterical or paranoid. The fact that a very senior police inspector was apparently asked to investigate the Sunday Times while thousands of murders and rapes go unsolved seems at best like a scandalous misdirection of resources.
But if it is true – as the Sunday Times story suggests – that important people in
This is deeply troubling for at least two reasons.
First, if true it would conform that the President is prepared to do anything to get his way – even if that means using his influence with those cadres deployed by the ANC to positions in independent institutions to pursue his enemies. It suggests that our President is ruthless and that he does not respect the constitutional and legal boundaries that should exist between him and those in charge of other state institutions.
Secondly, it must make us wonder what happens if the President abuses his power in the way alleged? Where does that leave our constitutional democracy, our independent courts, our institutions that have to safeguard democracy. If the President gets away with the firing of Pikoli and the persecution of the Sunday Times, will people in future be brave enough to stand up to him? Will we have more Vusi Pikoli’s or will we all cower and cringe and say nothing?
This is where I am an optimist. Unlike Justice Malala, I do not see a society meekly going along while President Mbeki does a Vladimir Putin on us and steal our democracy from under our noses. There are powerful voices in the print and electronic media and powerful civil society organs that will resist any moves to take away our democracy.
There are of course the traditional bootlickers like Christine Quanta or Essop Pahad that would claim the earth is flat if the President says so, but by and large we are not a passive nation. Yes, when a issue is racialised we tend to hunker down with our own kind, but President Mbeki’s weird and paranoid behaviour crosses all boundaries and must be upsetting to all but the most sycophantic ANC supporters.
That is why we should watch out for the Mbeki arse-lickers in the next few days because surely they will try and racialise the criticism of Mbeki. But I do not think it will work – just as the attempt to racialise the Treatment Action Campaigns fight for ARV’s could not be racialised. Watch out Mbeki, South Africans are not stupid and they like democracy too much.
Surely, your days must be numbered, Mr President?BACK TO TOP